What kills me about Jim Bob and Michelle Duggar is not the fact that they have sixteen children all named with J names. Even Michelle’s extreme-mullet hair doesn’t bother me (too much) and Jim Bob can’t really help that his name is Jim Bob, right?
I just can’t get over the fact that she can appear on television a day or two after giving birth to her sixteenth baby while looking so incredibly chipper and awake. And her children, even the seven little in-a-row boys all sit quietly and literally smile when the camera pans by them.
She’s a better woman than I. Put me in a line-up with her, ask someone to identify the superior mother and they’d pick her. No question.
If a camera panned my home, they’d see the dinner plates sticky with pancake syrup from last night’s makeshift dinner. (My husband wasn’t home for dinner again.) They’d see “Higgley-Town Heroes” on television and in the same room, a portable DVD player playing “Veggietales.” My daughter is tossing Goldfish crackers to my son. School-at-home paperwork litters my desk. My Reluctant Student sits bleary-eyed at the kitchen table a full hour before he normally stumbles from his room. He’s desperate to have at least part of the day off. (It’s a Teacher In-Service day and my 7-year old has the day off.) Occasionally, he shouts out complaints that I’ve ruined his life by giving him too much work.
The “Quiverfull” folks add children to their families routinely, tallying up another mark of blessing from God. The problem I have with the whole “children are a blessing from God” party-line is the unspoken corollary, which is “those who do not have children have not been blessed by God.” (And then there is the woman who calls herself “The Comic Mom,” who doesn’t think adoptions should be done. Ever.)
Believe me, in the days when I was trying to get pregnant without success, I did feel like God had turned His omnipotent back on me. My friends were conceiving while using birth control. I was like a fertility talisman–everyone in my sphere of influence became pregnant. Except me. I spent more days than I care to remember carefully wiping mascara from under my eyes, trying to look like I was not crying, when, in fact, I couldn’t stop crying. All this angst because I was not a mother.
The question is, did God make me infertile becuase He loves me less? Or does He loves me less because I’ve only been pregnant twice? Are the arrival of babies the surest sign of God’s blessing? Because that’s the message I get from women like Michelle Duggar who blithely portray a perfect family crammed with smiling children who never appear on camera with so much as a runny-nose, let alone a foot-stomping fit. She runs a tight ship. No question about that.
But I am not inspired to do the same. In fact, I feel the tiniest bit enraged at this woman who seems to be living a life which she planned exactly, down to the matching pinafores on her daughters and the straight parts in her sons’ hair. I mean, doesn’t she ever wake up and think, Today I am too tired to be a mother. Does she ever do the math in her head to figure out when the last kid will be gone? Does she have any flaws (beyond that misguided hairstyle)? And how does she get those kids to sit still? Don’t things ever happen in her family that cause her to shriek and say things she regrets like, “YOU ARE DRIVING ME CRAZY!”?
Kudos to Michelle and Jim Bob and their ever-expanding family rosy-cheeked children. I just wish they’d stop appearing on television looking as if they never break a sweat. Are their superior reproductive systems a sign of God’s ultimate blessing? And if so, what did I do to forfeit a similar blessing? Or is it simply a matter of biology, nothing more?
And is shutting down the reproductive factory the same as telling God, “No thank you. No more blessings for me,” as Jim Bob and Michelle would have us believe?
[Update: I did see the entire family appearing on a night-time news program and this time, the baby was screaming and the little boys were fidgeting and that made me feel OH SO MUCH BETTER about my inadequate mothering. Thank you, Michelle.]

